US Patent No: 6,173,261

Number of patents in Portfolio can not be more than 2000

Grammar fragment acquisition using syntactic and semantic clustering

3 Status Updates

Stats

ATTORNEY / AGENT: (SPONSORED)

Importance

Loading Importance Indicators... loading....

Abstract

See full text

A method and apparatus are provided for automatically acquiring grammar fragments for recognizing and understanding fluently spoken language. Grammar fragments representing a set of syntactically and semantically similar phrases may be generated using three probability distributions: of succeeding words, of preceding words, and of associated call-types. The similarity between phrases may be measured by applying Kullback-Leibler distance to these three probability distributions. Phrases being close in all three distances may be clustered into a grammar fragment.

Loading the Abstract Image... loading....

First Claim

See full text

Family

Loading Family data... loading....

Patent Owner(s)

Patent OwnerAddressTotal Patents
AT&T INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY II, L.P.RENO, NV2011
NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE CORPORATIONTOKYO1324

International Classification(s)

  • [Classification Symbol]
  • [Patents Count]

Inventor(s)

Inventor Name Address # of filed Patents Total Citations
Arai, Kazuhiro Kanagawa, JP 58 561
Gorin, Allen Louis Berkeley Heights, NJ 59 1832
Riccardi, Giuseppe Hoboken, NJ 67 1138
Wright, Jeremy Huntley Warren, NJ 24 667

Cited Art Landscape

Patent Info (Count) # Cites Year
 
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHINES CORPORATION (1)
* 6,023,673 Hierarchical labeler in a speech recognition system 33 1997
 
APPLE INC. (1)
* 5,839,106 Large-vocabulary speech recognition using an integrated syntactic and semantic statistical language model 152 1996
 
LUCENT TECHNOLOGIES INC. (1)
* 5,794,193 Automated phrase generation 69 1995
 
DRAGON SYSTEMS, INC. (1)
* 4,903,305 Method for representing word models for use in speech recognition 153 1989
 
KABUSHIKI KAISHA TOSHIBA (1)
* 5,457,768 Speech recognition apparatus using syntactic and semantic analysis 87 1992
 
MATSUSHITA ELECTRIC INDUSTRIAL CO., LTD. (1)
* 5,099,425 Method and apparatus for analyzing the semantics and syntax of a sentence or a phrase 75 1989
 
AT&T CORP. (2)
5,675,707 Automated call router system and method 154 1995
5,860,063 Automated meaningful phrase clustering 144 1997
* Cited By Examiner

Patent Citation Ranking

Forward Cite Landscape

Patent Info (Count) # Cites Year
 
Other [Check patent profile for assignment information] (5)
7,392,174 Natural-language processing system using a large corpus 3 2001
* 2004/0024,583 Natural-language processing system using a large corpus 5 2002
* 8,229,733 Method and apparatus for linguistic independent parsing in a natural language systems 1 2006
* 2007/0185,702 Language independent parsing in natural language systems 8 2006
* 2010/0048,256 Automated Response To And Sensing Of User Activity In Portable Devices 48 2009
 
NANT HOLDINGS IP, LLC (7)
8,374,871 Methods for creating a phrase thesaurus 50 2002
8,442,812 Phrase-based dialogue modeling with particular application to creating a recognition grammar for a voice-controlled user interface 3 2004
* 2004/0199,375 Phrase-based dialogue modeling with particular application to creating a recognition grammar for a voice-controlled user interface 121 2004
8,650,026 Methods for creating a phrase thesaurus 1 2013
8,630,846 Phrase-based dialogue modeling with particular application to creating a recognition grammar 0 2013
* 2014/0136,189 Phrase-Based Dialogue Modeling With Particular Application to Creating a Recognition Grammar 0 2014
9,251,138 Phrase-based dialogue modeling with particular application to creating recognition grammars for voice-controlled user interfaces 0 2014
 
LYMBA CORPORATION (2)
* 8,380,511 System and method for semantic categorization 7 2007
* 2008/0201,133 SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR SEMANTIC CATEGORIZATION 13 2007
 
NUANCE COMMUNICATIONS, INC. (48)
* 7,072,837 Method for processing initially recognized speech in a speech recognition session 16 2001
* 2002/0133,346 Method for processing initially recognized speech in a speech recognition session 7 2001
* 7,143,035 Methods and apparatus for generating dialog state conditioned language models 7 2002
* 2003/0187,648 Methods and apparatus for generating dialog state conditioned language models 6 2002
7,392,185 Speech based learning/training system using semantic decoding 102 2003
7,725,307 Query engine for processing voice based queries including semantic decoding 107 2003
9,076,448 Distributed real time speech recognition system 2 2003
8,032,358 Classifying text via topical analysis, for applications to speech recognition 4 2003
* 2006/0074,668 Method to assign word class information 0 2003
7,555,431 Method for processing speech using dynamic grammars 111 2004
7,376,556 Method for processing speech signal features for streaming transport 86 2004
7,729,904 Partial speech processing device and method for use in distributed systems 96 2004
7,702,508 System and method for natural language processing of query answers 89 2004
7,657,424 System and method for processing sentence based queries 103 2004
7,624,007 System and method for natural language processing of sentence based queries 90 2004
* 2005/0086,049 System & method for processing sentence based queries 11 2004
* 2005/0086,046 System & method for natural language processing of sentence based queries 9 2004
* 2005/0080,614 System & method for natural language processing of query answers 16 2004
7,277,854 Speech recognition system interactive agent 141 2005
7,225,125 Speech recognition system trained with regional speech characteristics 95 2005
7,139,714 Adjustable resource based speech recognition system 85 2005
* 2005/0144,004 Speech recognition system interactive agent 13 2005
* 2005/0119,896 Adjustable resource based speech recognition system 1 2005
* 2005/0119,897 Multi-language speech recognition system 73 2005
7,831,426 Network based interactive speech recognition system 103 2006
* 2006/0235,696 Network based interactive speech recognition system 10 2006
* 8,086,463 Dynamically generating a vocal help prompt in a multimodal application 32 2006
* 2008/0065,390 Dynamically Generating a Vocal Help Prompt in a Multimodal Application 62 2006
7,647,225 Adjustable resource based speech recognition system 88 2006
8,352,277 Method of interacting through speech with a web-connected server 9 2007
7,725,320 Internet based speech recognition system with dynamic grammars 90 2007
7,698,131 Speech recognition system for client devices having differing computing capabilities 80 2007
* 2007/0179,789 Speech Recognition System With Support For Variable Portable Devices 2 2007
8,762,152 Speech recognition system interactive agent 0 2007
9,190,063 Multi-language speech recognition system 0 2007
7,912,702 Statistical language model trained with semantic variants 74 2007
7,873,519 Natural language speech lattice containing semantic variants 108 2007
* 7,853,449 Methods and apparatus for generating dialog state conditioned language models 0 2008
* 2008/0215,329 Methods and Apparatus for Generating Dialog State Conditioned Language Models 2 2008
7,672,841 Method for processing speech data for a distributed recognition system 76 2008
* 2008/0300,878 Method For Transporting Speech Data For A Distributed Recognition System 72 2008
8,229,734 Semantic decoding of user queries 3 2008
7,725,321 Speech based query system using semantic decoding 77 2008
* 2009/0157,401 Semantic Decoding of User Queries 72 2008
* 2008/0255,845 Speech Based Query System Using Semantic Decoding 10 2008
* 8,612,209 Classifying text via topical analysis, for applications to speech recognition 0 2011
* 2012/0010,875 CLASSIFYING TEXT VIA TOPICAL ANALYSIS, FOR APPLICATIONS TO SPEECH RECOGNITION 4 2011
8,965,753 Method to assign word class information 0 2013
 
XEROX CORPORATION (4)
* 8,374,844 Hybrid system for named entity resolution 4 2007
* 2008/0319,978 HYBRID SYSTEM FOR NAMED ENTITY RESOLUTION 17 2007
* 8,370,128 Semantically-driven extraction of relations between named entities 3 2008
* 2010/0082,331 SEMANTICALLY-DRIVEN EXTRACTION OF RELATIONS BETWEEN NAMED ENTITIES 18 2008
 
UNIFY GMBH & CO. KG (1)
7,162,424 Method and system for defining a sequence of sound modules for synthesis of a speech signal in a tonal language 0 2002
 
PARITY COMMUNICATIONS, INC. (2)
7,366,759 Method and system for characterizing relationships in social networks 99 2002
* 2002/0116,466 Characterizing relationships in social networks 59 2002
 
DW ASSOCIATES, LLC (1)
9,020,807 Format for displaying text analytics results 0 2013
 
ORACLE INTERNATIONAL CORPORATION (1)
7,177,922 Policy enforcement using the semantic characterization of traffic 8 2000
 
ADACEL SYSTEMS, INC. (2)
* 8,515,734 Integrated language model, related systems and methods 1 2010
* 2011/0196,668 Integrated Language Model, Related Systems and Methods 2 2010
 
APPLE INC. (58)
* 7,149,695 Method and apparatus for speech recognition using semantic inference and word agglomeration 21 2000
8,677,377 Method and apparatus for building an intelligent automated assistant 13 2006
* 2008/0129,520 ELECTRONIC DEVICE WITH ENHANCED AUDIO FEEDBACK 71 2006
8,977,255 Method and system for operating a multi-function portable electronic device using voice-activation 0 2007
8,645,137 Fast, language-independent method for user authentication by voice 6 2007
9,053,089 Part-of-speech tagging using latent analogy 0 2007
8,620,662 Context-aware unit selection 3 2007
* 2009/0177,300 Methods and apparatus for altering audio output signals 2 2008
8,996,376 Intelligent text-to-speech conversion 0 2008
8,768,702 Multi-tiered voice feedback in an electronic device 0 2008
* 2010/0063,818 MULTI-TIERED VOICE FEEDBACK IN AN ELECTRONIC DEVICE 4 2008
8,898,568 Audio user interface 8 2008
* 2010/0064,218 AUDIO USER INTERFACE 15 2008
8,712,776 Systems and methods for selective text to speech synthesis 3 2008
8,583,418 Systems and methods of detecting language and natural language strings for text to speech synthesis 2 2008
* 2010/0082,349 SYSTEMS AND METHODS FOR SELECTIVE TEXT TO SPEECH SYNTHESIS 20 2008
8,676,904 Electronic devices with voice command and contextual data processing capabilities 2 2008
* 2009/0164,441 METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR SEARCHING USING AN ACTIVE ONTOLOGY 84 2008
8,862,252 Audio user interface for displayless electronic device 0 2009
* 2010/0312,547 CONTEXTUAL VOICE COMMANDS 94 2009
8,614,431 Automated response to and sensing of user activity in portable devices 5 2009
8,682,649 Sentiment prediction from textual data 7 2009
* 2011/0112,825 SENTIMENT PREDICTION FROM TEXTUAL DATA 9 2009
8,600,743 Noise profile determination for voice-related feature 1 2010
* 2011/0166,856 NOISE PROFILE DETERMINATION FOR VOICE-RELATED FEATURE 2 2010
8,682,667 User profiling for selecting user specific voice input processing information 8 2010
8,713,021 Unsupervised document clustering using latent semantic density analysis 1 2010
8,719,006 Combined statistical and rule-based part-of-speech tagging for text-to-speech synthesis 2 2010
8,719,014 Electronic device with text error correction based on voice recognition data 1 2010
9,318,108 Intelligent automated assistant 0 2011
8,781,836 Hearing assistance system for providing consistent human speech 0 2011
9,262,612 Device access using voice authentication 0 2011
8,812,294 Translating phrases from one language into another using an order-based set of declarative rules 0 2011
8,706,472 Method for disambiguating multiple readings in language conversion 4 2011
8,762,156 Speech recognition repair using contextual information 6 2011
8,688,446 Providing text input using speech data and non-speech data 8 2011
8,775,442 Semantic search using a single-source semantic model 7 2012
8,762,469 Electronic devices with voice command and contextual data processing capabilities 0 2012
8,713,119 Electronic devices with voice command and contextual data processing capabilities 0 2012
8,670,985 Devices and methods for identifying a prompt corresponding to a voice input in a sequence of prompts 0 2012
8,935,167 Exemplar-based latent perceptual modeling for automatic speech recognition 0 2012
9,117,447 Using event alert text as input to an automated assistant 0 2012
8,942,986 Determining user intent based on ontologies of domains 1 2012
8,903,716 Personalized vocabulary for digital assistant 0 2012
8,892,446 Service orchestration for intelligent automated assistant 3 2012
8,799,000 Disambiguation based on active input elicitation by intelligent automated assistant 1 2012
8,706,503 Intent deduction based on previous user interactions with voice assistant 8 2012
8,670,979 Active input elicitation by intelligent automated assistant 2 2012
8,660,849 Prioritizing selection criteria by automated assistant 5 2012
8,718,047 Text to speech conversion of text messages from mobile communication devices 0 2012
9,311,043 Adaptive audio feedback system and method 0 2013
8,751,238 Systems and methods for determining the language to use for speech generated by a text to speech engine 1 2013
8,930,191 Paraphrasing of user requests and results by automated digital assistant 1 2013
8,731,942 Maintaining context information between user interactions with a voice assistant 2 2013
9,280,610 Crowd sourcing information to fulfill user requests 0 2013
9,075,783 Electronic device with text error correction based on voice recognition data 0 2013
9,190,062 User profiling for voice input processing 0 2014
9,300,784 System and method for emergency calls initiated by voice command 0 2014
 
AVAYA INC. (3)
* 2003/0088,403 Call classification by automatic recognition of speech 7 2001
* 2003/0081,756 Multi-detector call classifier 4 2001
7,054,435 Apparatus and method for determining a minimal time bound for performing tone detection 0 2002
 
MICROSOFT TECHNOLOGY LICENSING, LLC (12)
* 7,080,004 Grammar authoring system 16 2001
* 2003/0121,026 Grammar authoring system 3 2001
7,031,918 Generating a task-adapted acoustic model from one or more supervised and/or unsupervised corpora 18 2002
* 7,006,972 Generating a task-adapted acoustic model from one or more different corpora 5 2002
* 2003/0182,121 Generating a task-adapted acoustic model from one or more different corpora 2 2002
* 2003/0182,120 Generating a task-adapted acoustic model from one or more supervised and/or unsupervised corpora 3 2002
7,263,487 Generating a task-adapted acoustic model from one or more different corpora 2 2005
* 2006/0036,444 Generating a task-adapted acoustic model from one or more different corpora 4 2005
* 8,249,871 Word clustering for input data 6 2005
* 2007/0118,376 Word clustering for input data 8 2005
8,244,521 Paraphrasing the web by search-based data collection 2 2007
* 2008/0172,378 Paraphrasing the web by search-based data collection 3 2007
 
TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED (7)
7,712,031 System and process for developing a voice application 8 2003
* 2006/0025,997 System and process for developing a voice application 21 2003
8,046,227 Development system for a dialog system 15 2003
* 7,917,363 System for predicting speech recognition accuracy and development for a dialog system 3 2004
* 2006/0190,252 System for predicting speech recognition accuracy and development for a dialog system 11 2004
8,296,129 System and process for grammatical inference 0 2004
* 2008/0126,078 A System and Process For Grammatical Interference 4 2004
 
GOOGLE INC. (8)
* 6,510,411 Task oriented dialog model and manager 128 1999
* 7,657,423 Automatic completion of fragments of text 13 2003
* 2008/0133,365 Targeted Marketing System 3 2007
* 8,219,385 Computer-implemented method and system for conducting a search of electronically stored information 2 2008
* 2009/0254,337 COMPUTER-IMPLEMENTED METHOD AND SYSTEM FOR CONDUCTING A SEARCH OF ELECTRONICALLY STORED INFORMATION 1 2008
8,024,178 Automatic completion of fragments of text 1 2009
8,280,722 Automatic completion of fragments of text 1 2011
8,521,515 Automatic completion of fragments of text 1 2012
 
ELECTRONICS AND TELECOMMUNICATIONS RESEARCH INSTITUTE (1)
* 2006/0129,393 System and method for synthesizing dialog-style speech using speech-act information 2 2005
 
RAKUTEN, INC. (1)
* 7,224,790 Method to identify and categorize customer's goals and behaviors within a customer service center environment 8 2000
 
WOLF, WARREN L. (4)
8,577,718 Methods and systems for identifying, quantifying, analyzing, and optimizing the level of engagement of components within a defined ecosystem or context 0 2011
8,996,359 Taxonomy and application of language analysis and processing 0 2012
8,952,796 Enactive perception device 0 2012
9,269,353 Methods and systems for measuring semantics in communications 0 2012
 
KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS ELECTRONICS N.V. (1)
* 2003/0061,024 Method of determining sequences of terminals or of terminals and wildcards belonging to non-terminals of a grammar 1 2002
 
SAP SE (1)
* 8,156,142 Semantically weighted searching in a governed corpus of terms 0 2008
 
SEHDA, INC. (1)
* 2002/0032,564 Phrase-based dialogue modeling with particular application to creating a recognition grammar for a voice-controlled user interface 167 2001
 
NOVELL, INC. (4)
8,386,475 Attribution analysis and correlation 2 2008
8,301,622 Identity analysis and correlation 2 2008
8,296,297 Content analysis and correlation 2 2008
* 2010/0169,314 CONTENT ANALYSIS AND CORRELATION 7 2008
 
THE BANK OF NEW YORK (2)
* 2003/0086,541 Call classifier using automatic speech recognition to separately process speech and tones 16 2001
* 2003/0083,875 Unified call classifier for processing speech and tones as a single information stream 8 2001
 
Eliza Corporation (8)
7,366,766 Web-based speech recognition with scripting and semantic objects 7 2001
7,120,585 Remote server object architecture for speech recognition 8 2001
6,868,380 Speech recognition system and method for generating phonotic estimates 38 2001
* 2002/0002,463 Web-based speech recognition with scripting and semantic objects 0 2001
7,370,086 Web-based speech recognition with scripting and semantic objects 11 2002
* 2002/0138,262 Web-based speech recognition with scripting and semantic objects 0 2002
8,024,422 Web-based speech recognition with scripting and semantic objects 0 2008
8,510,412 Web-based speech recognition with scripting and semantic objects 1 2011
 
MMODAL IP LLC (4)
* 8,335,688 Document transcription system training 4 2004
* 2006/0041,427 Document transcription system training 21 2004
8,412,521 Discriminative training of document transcription system 3 2005
* 2006/0074,656 Discriminative training of document transcription system 29 2005
 
TELLME NETWORKS, INC. (1)
* 2002/0077,833 Transcription and reporting system 57 2000
 
Newvaluexchange Global AI LLP (1)
8,977,584 Apparatuses, methods and systems for a digital conversation management platform 0 2011
 
Varcode Ltd. (2)
9,135,544 System and method for quality management utilizing barcode indicators 0 2013
9,317,794 Barcoded indicators for quality management 0 2013
 
GINGER SOFTWARE, INC. (4)
* 8,914,278 Automatic context sensitive language correction and enhancement using an internet corpus 0 2008
* 2010/0286,979 AUTOMATIC CONTEXT SENSITIVE LANGUAGE CORRECTION AND ENHANCEMENT USING AN INTERNET CORPUS 37 2008
9,015,036 Automatic context sensitive language correction using an internet corpus particularly for small keyboard devices 0 2011
9,026,432 Automatic context sensitive language generation, correction and enhancement using an internet corpus 0 2013
 
AT&T INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY II, L.P. (17)
* 7,085,720 Method for task classification using morphemes 19 2000
7,158,935 Method and system for predicting problematic situations in a automated dialog 25 2000
8,392,188 Method and system for building a phonotactic model for domain independent speech recognition 2 2001
7,286,984 Method and system for automatically detecting morphemes in a task classification system using lattices 14 2002
* 7,263,486 Active learning for spoken language understanding 8 2003
* 8,185,399 System and method of providing an automated data-collection in spoken dialog systems 6 2005
* 2006/0149,555 System and method of providing an automated data-collection in spoken dialog systems 23 2005
7,957,970 Method and system for predicting problematic situations in automated dialog 3 2006
7,742,918 Active learning for spoken language understanding 1 2007
7,620,548 Method and system for automatic detecting morphemes in a task classification system using lattices 5 2007
8,010,361 Method and system for automatically detecting morphemes in a task classification system using lattices 5 2008
8,200,491 Method and system for automatically detecting morphemes in a task classification system using lattices 3 2011
8,694,324 System and method of providing an automated data-collection in spoken dialog systems 1 2012
8,612,212 Method and system for automatically detecting morphemes in a task classification system using lattices 1 2013
9,240,197 Library of existing spoken dialog data for use in generating new natural language spoken dialog systems 0 2013
8,909,529 Method and system for automatically detecting morphemes in a task classification system using lattices 0 2013
8,914,294 System and method of providing an automated data-collection in spoken dialog systems 1 2014
 
BRITISH TELECOMMUNICATIONS PUBLIC LIMITED COMPANY (2)
* 6,839,671 Learning of dialogue states and language model of spoken information system 36 2002
* 2003/0091,163 Learning of dialogue states and language model of spoken information system 4 2002
 
SAP AG (1)
* 2010/0161,601 SEMANTICALLY WEIGHTED SEARCHING IN A GOVERNED CORPUS OF TERMS 5 2008
 
INTEL CORPORATION (2)
* 7,257,529 Apparatus and method for an automated grammar file expansion tool 5 2001
* 2003/0050,772 Apparatus and method for an automated grammar file expansion tool 3 2001
 
NIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE CORPORATION (1)
* 8,666,744 Grammar fragment acquisition using syntactic and semantic clustering 0 2000
 
RPX CORPORATION (11)
7,152,031 Construction, manipulation, and comparison of a multi-dimensional semantic space 40 2000
* 7,197,451 Method and mechanism for the creation, maintenance, and comparison of semantic abstracts 63 2000
7,286,977 Intentional-stance characterization of a general content stream or repository 23 2000
7,389,225 Method and mechanism for superpositioning state vectors in a semantic abstract 34 2000
7,562,011 Intentional-stance characterization of a general content stream or repository 23 2006
* 2007/0073,531 INTENTIONAL-STANCE CHARACTERIZATION OF A GENERAL CONTENT STREAM OR REPOSITORY 3 2006
7,653,530 Method and mechanism for the creation, maintenance, and comparison of semantic abstracts 14 2006
* 2007/0106,491 METHOD AND MECHANISM FOR THE CREATION, MAINTENANCE, AND COMPARISON OF SEMANTIC ABSTRACTS 5 2006
7,672,952 System and method of semantic correlation of rich content 15 2006
8,131,741 Construction, manipulation, and comparison of a multi-dimensional semantic space 0 2007
* 2008/0052,283 CONSTRUCTION, MANIPULATION, AND COMPARISON OF A MULTI-DIMENSIONAL SEMANTIC SPACE 5 2007
 
FRANCE TELECOM (2)
* 6,973,168 Method of identifying a caller with a telephone service operator 1 2001
* 2004/0022,374 Method of identifying a caller with a telephone service operator 0 2003
 
VOX GENERATION LIMITED (1)
* 2005/0154,580 Automated grammar generator (AGG) 97 2004
 
NOVELL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY HOLDINGS, INC. (2)
* 2010/0122,312 PREDICTIVE SERVICE SYSTEMS 0 2008
* 2009/0234,718 PREDICTIVE SERVICE SYSTEMS USING EMOTION DETECTION 18 2009
 
AT&T ALEX HOLDINGS, LLC (10)
6,941,266 Method and system for predicting problematic dialog situations in a task classification system 63 2000
7,003,459 Method and system for predicting understanding errors in automated dialog systems 26 2001
6,751,591 Method and system for predicting understanding errors in a task classification system 82 2001
* 7,933,774 System and method for automatic generation of a natural language understanding model 6 2004
7,127,395 Method and system for predicting understanding errors in a task classification system 30 2004
7,529,667 Automated dialog system and method 6 2005
7,472,060 Automated dialog system and method 43 2005
7,440,893 Automated dialog method with first and second thresholds for adapted dialog strategy 7 2005
7,487,088 Method and system for predicting understanding errors in a task classification system 44 2006
* 7,933,773 Natural language understanding monitoring system for identifying a task 1 2009
 
AT&T CORP. (4)
* 6,415,248 Method for building linguistic models from a corpus 18 1999
7,139,698 System and method for generating morphemes 4 2003
7,440,897 Method and system for automatically detecting morphemes in a task classification system using lattices 7 2006
* 2008/0177,544 METHOD AND SYSTEM FOR AUTOMATIC DETECTING MORPHEMES IN A TASK CLASSIFICATION SYSTEM USING LATTICES 0 2007
* Cited By Examiner